How disruption turned Austrian GP on its head


James Allen analyses the Austrian Grand Prix, as Pink Bull took full benefit of a Digital Security Automobile, and Mercedes fluffed its strategic traces.

Disruption is all over the place within the trendy world, few can escape it. It has all the time been true of Components 1, the place technological innovation performs such a significant half in success. 

However we additionally discover disruption within the race methods. A race that appeared beneath management might be turned on its head by a Security Automobile or a Digital Security Automobile and the problem is disrupted.

F1 group race strategists have skilled most situations and all of it comes right down to calculation and urge for food for danger. Groups which might be used to successful, like Mercedes within the present system, have a low urge for food for danger. Whereas challenger groups like Pink Bull like to take dangers, particularly once they don’t clearly have a quick sufficient automobile to win beneath regular circumstances.

A Digital Security Automobile disrupted the Austrian GP – 5 of the groups determined to depart a automobile out: Mercedes, Pressure India, Williams, Toro Rosso and Haas. Half the sector acquired it proper and half acquired it improper…

Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes-AMG F1 W09 retires from the race

Photograph by: Jerry Andre / Sutton Photographs 

Digital Security Automobile catches out Mercedes

The Digital Security Automobile was launched after the accident of Jules Bianchi at Suzuka in 2014 and has performed an influential function within the end result of various races since.

Whereas the Security Automobile bunches the sector up and race strategists know that it will likely be out on monitor for a number of laps, to allow them to plan, a Digital Security Automobile is a extra fleeting disruption.

The strategists must second-guess not solely how lengthy the Race Director goes to maintain the VSC energetic for, but additionally whether or not the incident in query is extreme sufficient to warrant a change to a full Security Automobile. We’ve got seen various these in the previous few years. 

One other well-known event for Mercedes was Monaco 2015 once they misplaced monitor of time intervals as a Digital Security Automobile grew to become a Security Automobile and Lewis Hamilton misplaced the result in his teammate within the pits.

However the problem with the VSC is that there isn’t any approach of figuring out when it can finish. There isn’t a warning from Race Management, as there’s with a full Security Automobile. And the worst factor you are able to do is locate your self coming into the pit lane simply as a VSC ends. As you’ll lose time and plenty of monitor positions.

Within the case of Sunday’s Austrian Grand Prix, Valtteri Bottas’ Mercedes suffered a sudden lack of hydraulic strain on Lap 14 and pulled off the race monitor. This introduced out the VSC whereas the marshals cleared the automobile. 

Toto Wolff, Executive Director (Business), Mercedes AMG, with Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes AMG F1

Toto Wolff, Government Director (Enterprise), Mercedes AMG, with Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes AMG F1

Photograph by: Steve Etherington / LAT Photographs

Some strategists took the view that the VSC could be short-lived, others dived on the chance of a less expensive pitstop, saving round 9 to 10 seconds in comparison with a cease at racing speeds. 

There was loads of time to react because the chief Lewis Hamilton was solely approaching Flip 6 in the intervening time when the VSC was deployed, much more time for Max Verstappen, Kimi Raikkonen, Daniel Ricciardo and Sebastian Vettel who had been trailing in his wake. Verstappen was 5 seconds behind the Mercedes.

Max Verstappen, Red Bull Racing RB14, Sebastian Vettel, Ferrari SF71H, Daniel Ricciardo, Red Bull Racing RB14, Romain Grosjean, Haas F1 Team VF-18

Photograph by: Zak Mauger / LAT Photographs

In conditions like this the gamble is how lengthy the VSC will probably be out, however there was a clarification from Race Director Charlie Whiting that the VSC would all the time be out for not less than one lap.

This took away the possibility shorter deployment might create a lottery which massively advantaged one or two groups who occurred to be in the fitting place on the proper time.

The pondering of the strategists is commonly to do the other of the automobile they’re racing in opposition to. On this case, if Hamilton had pitted, Pink Bull might need cut up methods, leaving Verstappen out to achieve the monitor place and pitting Ricciardo.  

Ferrari had a quick sufficient automobile to race for the win, however having misplaced out in qualifying with Vettel and at first with Raikkonen, they had been focussed on beating Pink Bull.

The VSC got here at a horrible second within the race; it was too early to pit, because the race was set to be a one-stopper with the unique goal cease lap being between laps 20-28 to change to tender tyres, for the Mercedes and Pink Bulls utilizing supersoft tyres for the primary stint. 

Daniel Ricciardo, Red Bull Racing RB14, makes a pit stop

Daniel Ricciardo, Pink Bull Racing RB14, makes a pit cease

Photograph by: Glenn Dunbar / LAT Photographs

The limitation was tyre graining and particularly the left rear, because the monitor’s predominantly right-hand turns give lateral stress to that specific tyre. It was a lot hotter than throughout follow, which made it extra of a tyre administration train than anticipated.

For the Sauber group that had began Marcus Ericsson on tender tyres, it assured that they might rating factors because the tender tyre was the one tyre you could possibly keep out on with confidence that you could possibly push after the race went stay once more. When strategists with automobiles down the again of the sector go for a reverse technique (beginning on hardest tyres) it’s exactly for this state of affairs that they’re playing.  

Fernando Alonso, McLaren MCL33

Fernando Alonso, McLaren MCL33 leads Marcus Ericsson, Sauber C37

Photograph by: Manuel Goria / Sutton Photographs

Fernando Alonso did effectively to complete eighth having began from the pit lane, however think about how a lot additional up the sector he might need completed had he began on tender tyres given the best way the VSC turned out.

On the Mercedes pit wall, there was dialogue on what to do. The ultimate resolution in that group lies with James Vowles, who does the technique for each automobiles. During the last 5 years he has needed to assume in stereo on many events, however now there was solely Hamilton’s race to think about.

However on this case, the clock ran down for Mercedes and it missed the chance. Hamilton began a brand new lap and the 4 automobiles behind him all stopped. Different groups did the identical factor, however the Mercedes instance was probably the most excessive profile.

The calculation was whether or not Hamilton might pull out over eight seconds on Verstappen on worn supersoft tyres, in opposition to the brand new softs on Verstappen’s automobile.

Pink Bull and Ferrari had been absolutely dedicated to stopping; a lot in order that they pitted each automobiles, which price the tail automobile in every case – Vettel and Ricciardo – three extra seconds of race time. To do this they needed to put together two units of tyres in double fast time, which Mercedes would concentrate on as they deliberated.

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes-AMG F1 W09 pit stop

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes-AMG F1 W09 pit cease

Photograph by: Mark Sutton / Sutton Photographs 

Hamilton didn’t have the tempo on fading tyres to drag the hole and dropped to fourth at his cease on Lap 25. Ferrari missed a trick in not preserving Vettel protected to Hamilton, in different phrases getting him to hurry as much as preserve a pitstop hole to the Mercedes, which might have put Hamilton fifth after his cease. 

They made up for it with one other tactic which was to again Hamilton up into Vettel as soon as the Mercedes caught Raikkonen, who had been overtaken by Ricciardo early within the second stint. 

The upper temperatures on race day meant that the tyres had been graining and the successful tactic was to take care of them fairly than to push, as Ricciardo did in his assault on Raikkonen. He was compelled to make an additional pit cease. 

Daniel Ricciardo, Red Bull Racing RB14, battles Kimi Raikkonen, Ferrari SF71H

Daniel Ricciardo, Pink Bull Racing RB14, battles Kimi Raikkonen, Ferrari SF71H

Photograph by: Steven Tee / LAT Photographs

It’s shocking that this occurred in some ways, as there was clear indication from the injury sustained by the tyres from the primary stint that it was important to take care of the second set to make the end and that might have been communicated to the drivers. Verstappen definitely heeded it and it gained him the race. However Ricciardo was in a racy temper.

In clear air on the entrance Verstappen was in a position to handle his tyres, as did the Ferraris, which had one of the best efficiency on the tyres on the weekend. 

Vettel took the championship lead by one level, however it might have been extra. If Ferrari had switched the automobiles round, Vettel would have gained one other three factors. 

Sebastian Vettel, Ferrari SF71H crosses the line

Sebastian Vettel, Ferrari SF71H crosses the road

Photograph by: Jerry Andre / Sutton Photographs

And if he had not blocked Sainz unnecessarily in qualifying, selecting up a three-place grid penalty, he would have began in third place on ultrasoft tyres – forward of Verstappen – and with Mercedes’ double technical retirement, he’d have scooped 25 factors to Hamilton’s zero.

It is simple to say in hindsight, however one of many secrets and techniques of Michael Schumacher’s success at Ferrari was by no means giving something away to the opposition, particularly by way of unforced errors, of which now we have seen a quantity from Vettel this 12 months. 

The usRace Technique Report is written by James Allen with enter and knowledge from a number of F1 group strategists and from Pirelli.

Race Historical past Chart

Race history

Kindly offered by Williams Martini Racing, click on to enlarge

The variety of laps is on the horizontal axis; the hole behind the chief is on the vertical axis. 

A constructive signal is an upward curve because the gasoline load burns off. A damaging signal is the slope declining because the tyre degradation kicks in.

Tyre Utilization Chart

Tyre history